---
title: Was Ram Charan Right About Splitting HR?
description: Ram Charan recommended splitting HR into two separate functions. Other experts disagreed. What's your opinion about how we can improve HR?
image: https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/hubfs/iStock-1011792700.jpg
---
[ ](https://www.neocasesoftware.com)
- Product
- [Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/)
- [Neocase HR](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-hr-solution)
- [Neocase HR Ready](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-hr-ready-solution)
- [Neocase Employee Journey](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-employee-journey)
- [Neocase Employee Relations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-employee-relations)
- [Modules](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules)
- [Self-Service Portal](https://www.neocasesoftware.com//hris-modules/hr-self-service-portal)
- [Case & Knowledge Management](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/hr-case-and-knowledge-management)
- [Business Processes Management](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/business-process-management)
- [Employee Document Management](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/employee-document-management/)
- [People Analytics](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/reports-and-analytics)
- [Finance Extension](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/finance-extension)
- [Services](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/services)
- [Pricing](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/services)
- [Integrations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations)
- [Our integrations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations)
- [Microsoft Teams](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/microsoft-teams)
- [Workday](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/worday)
- [Dayforce](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/dayforce-and-neocase-integration/https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/dayforce-and-neocase-integration/)
- [Access](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-and-access-peoplexd-integration/)
- [Cegid](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/cegid-and-neocase-integration/)
- [e-Signature Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/e-signature-integrations/)
- [Other Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/hris-ecosystem-integration/)
- [Sopra HR 4YOU](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-and-sopra-hr-integration/)
- [SAP SuccessFactors](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-integrated-to-sap-successfactors/)
- [ADP](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/adp-neocase-integration/)
- [Oracle HCM](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-oracle-hcm-integration/)
- Case Studies
- [Success Stories](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/success-stories)
- [Use Cases](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-use-cases)
- Resources
- [Blog](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com)
- [Resources Center](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-resources)
- About
- [Contact us](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/contact-us-old)
- [Neocase by sopra HR](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/about-neocase)
- [Partners](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/our-partners)
- [Support](https://onlinesupport.neocasesoftware.com/)
[ Français](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/fr?hsLang=en) [ English](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/?hsLang=en)
[ ](https://www.neocasesoftware.com)
- Product
- [Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/)
- [Neocase HR](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-hr-solution)
- [Neocase HR Ready](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-hr-ready-solution)
- [Neocase Employee Journey](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-employee-journey)
- [Neocase Employee Relations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-employee-relations)
- [Modules](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules)
- [Self-Service Portal](https://www.neocasesoftware.com//hris-modules/hr-self-service-portal)
- [Case & Knowledge Management](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/hr-case-and-knowledge-management)
- [Business Processes Management](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/business-process-management)
- [Employee Document Management](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/employee-document-management/)
- [People Analytics](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/reports-and-analytics)
- [Finance Extension](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hris-modules/finance-extension)
- [Services](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/services)
- [Pricing](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/services)
- [Integrations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations)
- [Our integrations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations)
- [Microsoft Teams](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/microsoft-teams)
- [Workday](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/worday)
- [Dayforce](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/dayforce-and-neocase-integration/https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/dayforce-and-neocase-integration/)
- [Access](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-and-access-peoplexd-integration/)
- [Cegid](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/cegid-and-neocase-integration/)
- [e-Signature Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/e-signature-integrations/)
- [Other Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/hris-ecosystem-integration/)
- [Sopra HR 4YOU](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-and-sopra-hr-integration/)
- [SAP SuccessFactors](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-integrated-to-sap-successfactors/)
- [ADP](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/adp-neocase-integration/)
- [Oracle HCM](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-oracle-hcm-integration/)
- Case Studies
- [Success Stories](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/success-stories)
- [Use Cases](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-use-cases)
- Resources
- [Blog](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com)
- [Resources Center](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-resources)
- About
- [Contact us](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/contact-us-old)
- [Neocase by sopra HR](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/about-neocase)
- [Partners](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/our-partners)
- [Support](https://onlinesupport.neocasesoftware.com/)
Loading...
×
## Book a demo now
## And see it in action
Your details are 100% safe
- ### We will endeavor to get back to you within 24 hours and will schedule a demo based on availability
- ### The demo will be provided remotely to you and will last approximately 60 minutes
×
###### [HR Service Delivery](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/hr-service-delivery-posts)
# Was Ram Charan Right About Splitting HR?
Posted on [August 21, 2017](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/ram-charan-right-splitting-hr) by [Jim Watson](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/author/jim-watson)
[Home](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/) \> [Neocase Blog](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/ram-charan-right-splitting-hr) \> **Was Ram Charan Right About Splitting HR?**
Two years ago, Harvard Business Review published an article written by Ram Charan, the world-renowned [business adviser](http://www.ram-charan.com/about-ram/).
The article was called “[It’s Time to Split HR."](https://hbr.org/2014/07/its-time-to-split-hr) It's purpose to recommend how best to improve HR and its capability to deliver value to the business.
Charan proposed the elimination of the CHRO position, and the split of HR as we know it into two distinct strands. The reason for the split? Most CHRO’s, he says, can’t “relate HR to real-world business needs. They don’t know how key decisions are made, and they have great difficulty analyzing why people—or whole parts of the organization—aren’t meeting the business’s performance goals. “
That sounds harsh, doesn’t it? We’ll get to some of the rebuttals in a minute.
**Charan proposed that traditional HR be split into the following two strands:**
1. **HR for Administration**
2. **HR Leadership and Organization**
HR for Administration would handle – you guessed it – all the administrative, transactional stuff like compensation and benefits. This sounds a lot like the duties of the HR Shared Service Center, doesn’t it?
This HR for Administration (“HR-A”) as Charan called it, would report up to the CFO.
HR for Leadership and Organization (“HR-LO”) would handle things like developing people, assessing how work gets done, and aligning talent and staffing with organizational objectives. This sounds a lot like the strategic stuff that gets enabled through HR Transformation, doesn’t it?
“HR-LO” would report to the CEO, and would be staffed by high-potentials from areas outside of HR. Areas like operations and finance.
**The proposal was radical, and drew some opinionated response. More notable responses came from Dave Ulrich, and John Boudreau**.
You remember Dave Ulrich. He’s the Professor from The University of Michigan’s Ross School of Business who brought us “[The Ulrich Model](https://www.slideshare.net/CreativeHRM/david-ulrichs-hr-model)” for HR.
## How does Ulrich say we should improve HR?
Ulrich’s response to Charan’s proposal to split HR was lukewarm, at best. Shortly after Charan’s article was published in hard copy, Ulrich published “[Do Not Split HR – At Least Not Ram Charan’s Way](https://hbr.org/2014/07/do-not-split-hr-at-least-not-ram-charans-way).”
In the article, Ulrich says, “I believe CHROs have much to offer CEOs and can be better prepared to do so without splitting HR.” Rather than splitting HR, Ulrich recommends applying greater focus on the following two areas:
1. **Improving the capabilities of the [middle 60%](https://www.tlnt.com/it-takes-work-for-hr-to-be-taken-as-a-partner/) of HR professionals.** This is where the most untapped service potential of HR lies.
2. **Taking an “[Outside-in](http://hrfromtheoutsidein.com/)” approach, rather than “Inside out.”** In other words, HR can best serve the business when HR sees the business from the outside customer’s perspective, instead of the insider operational manager’s perspective.
John Boudreau is a research scientist at USC’s Center for Effective Organizations, and a frequent contributor to [CFO.com](http://ww2.cfo.com/author/john-boudreau/) and [hbr.org](https://hbr.org/search?search_type=search-all&term=john+boudreau). Boudreau published a response titled, “[It’s Time to Retool HR, Not Split It](https://hbr.org/2014/08/its-time-to-retool-hr-not-split-it). His criticism of Charan’s recommendation was more direct.
## How does Boudreau say we should improve HR?
“Let’s be clear. Ram Charan’s recommendation is wrong. CEOs and organization leaders who read only his column (or worse, only the title) and split HR as he suggests, will make a serious mistake that will destroy value for their shareholders and constituents.”
**Instead of splitting HR, Boudreau recommends “adapting financial and other management frameworks to HR and talent decisions.”** For example, retool total rewards by using the principles that have proven to work in product design and market segmentation. In other words, use methodologies that are effective in other functional areas of the enterprise, and apply them to HR.
**So, what’s your position?**
*Split HR?*
*Improve HR through the middle 60% and a more “Outside In” approach?*
*Or improve HR by applying best-practice methodologies from other domains inside the organization?*
Share this post
##### Jim Watson
Jim Watson is a Sr. Solution Consultant for HR Service Delivery at Neocase Software, and has been helping clients improve their Employee Experience, HR Productivity and Service Center Efficiency for over 10 years. He lives on the coast of Maine where he enjoys reading, writing and rowing which inspire his pursuit of the Perfect Service Experience!
### CATEGORIES
- [HR Service Delivery (231)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/hr-service-delivery-posts)
- [Press (35)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/press)
- [Experience collaborateur (33)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/experience-collaborateur)
- [Case Management (31)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/case-management)
- [Self-Service Portal (29)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/self-service-portal)
- [Product (26)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/product)
- [Employee Experience (22)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/employee-experience)
- [Knowledge Base (22)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/knowledge-base)
- [Best Practices (21)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/best-practices)
- [Business Process Automation (20)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/business-process-automation-posts)
- [Digital transformation (15)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/digital-transformation)
- [Future of HR (15)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/future-of-hr)
- [Feature (14)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/feature)
- [Artificial Intelligence (13)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/artificial-intelligence)
- [Events (12)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/events)
- [Fosway (12)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/fosway)
- [Partner (11)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/partner)
- [Employee Journey (10)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/employee-journey)
- [Employee Relations (10)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/employee-relations)
- [Employee Document Management (9)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/employee-document-management)
- [COVID-19 (8)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/covid-19)
- [Customers (7)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/customers)
- [Onboarding (7)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/onboarding)
- [Chatbot (6)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/chatbot)
- [Neocase HR (6)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/neocase-hr)
- [EDM (5)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/edm)
- [Data Confidentiality (4)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/data-confidentiality)
- [Manufacturing (4)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/manufacturing)
- [Analytics (3)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/analytics)
- [ERM (2)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/erm)
- [Monthly Updates (2)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/monthly-updates)
- [News (2)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/news)
- [Reporting (2)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/reporting)
- [Webinar (2)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/webinar)
- [offboarding (2)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/offboarding)
- [Artificiel Intelligence (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/artificiel-intelligence)
- [GED (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/ged)
- [Gartner (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/gartner)
- [Health and Safety at work (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/health-and-safety-at-work)
- [Professional Services (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/professional-services)
- [Quality of work (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/quality-of-work)
- [Shared Cervice Center (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/shared-cervice-center)
- [Success Story (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/success-story)
- [What is..? (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/what-is)
- [Workday connector (1)](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/workday-connector)
See all
## See the Power of [HR Service Delivery](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/book-demo?hsLang=en)
[Book a demo now](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/book-demo?hsLang=en)
Blog articles you don’t want to miss directly in your inbox
What is Neocase and how does it help HR teams?
Neocase is a cloud-based HR service delivery platform that automates HR processes, improves employee experience, and optimizes shared service center operations. It helps HR teams reduce manual tasks, increase efficiency, and deliver faster, more personalized services.
What are the main features of Neocase HR solutions?
Neocase offers a wide range of features, including:
- **Case Management** for handling employee requests efficiently
- **Knowledge Base** for self-service and quick answers
- **Document Management** for secure storage and compliance
- **Employee Self-Service Portals** for easy access to HR services
- **AI-powered Automation** to streamline workflows and reduce response times
- **Reports and Analytics** to monitor HR performance and manage key indicators.
Can Neocase integrate with existing HR systems like SAP SuccessFactors or Workday?
Yes. Neocase integrates seamlessly with leading HRIS platforms such as SAP SuccessFactors, Workday, and others. These integrations ensure smooth data exchange and process continuity without disrupting your existing HR ecosystem.
How does Neocase ensure data security and compliance?
Neocase is ISO 27001 certified and fully GDPR compliant. The platform uses secure cloud architecture, encryption, and strict access controls to protect sensitive HR data and maintain compliance with global regulations.
Is Neocase suitable for global organizations and multi-language environments?
Absolutely. Neocase supports multi-country deployments, multiple languages, and localization features, making it ideal for global organizations with diverse workforces.
How can I request a demo or learn more about pricing?
You can ask for informations by visiting our [Contact Page](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/get-in-touch?hsLang=en) or filling out the [demo request](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/book-demo?hsLang=en) form available on our website.
### Continue reading
[GDPR Compliance and HR Digitalization: What Companies Need to Know](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/gdpr-compliance-and-hr-digitalization-what-companies-need-to-know?hsLang=en)
[HR Chatbots: A Practical Guide to Conversational AI for HR Teams](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/hr-chatbots?hsLang=en)
[How the Public Sector Is Modernizing Its HR Services](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/how-the-public-sector-is-modernizing-its-hr-services?hsLang=en)
### [Solutions](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/)
- [Neocase HR](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-hr-solution/)
- [Neocase HR Ready](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-hr-ready-solution/)
- [Employee Journey](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-employee-journey/)
- [Employee Relations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/hr-solutions/neocase-employee-relations/)
### [Integrations](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/)
- [Workday](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/workday/)
- [Microsoft Teams](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/microsoft-teams/)
- [SAP SuccessFactors](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-integrated-to-sap-successfactors/)
- [Access](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/integrations/neocase-and-access-peoplexd-integration/)
### [About](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/about-neocase/)
- [Contact Us](https://info.neocasesoftware.com/get-in-touch)
- [Support](https://onlinesupport.neocasesoftware.com/)
- [The Company](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/about-neocase/)
- [Career](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/career/)
- [Partners](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/our-partners/)
- [Press Room](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/tag/press)
### Follow Us
[Blog](https://blog.neocasesoftware.com/fr?hsLang=en)
[Linkedin](https://www.linkedin.com/company/neocasesoftware/)
[Youtube](https://www.youtube.com/@NeocaseSoftwareInc)
### Subscribe
Receive the Neocase monthly newsletter
### Our addresses
**Neocase Software Northern America**
275 Grove St, Auburndale, Massachusetts 02466 USA
**Neocase Software Europe**
91 Boulevard National, La Garenne-Colombes 92250
- [Terms of use](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/terms-of-use)
- [Privacy Policy](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/privacy-policy)
- [Cookie Policy](https://www.neocasesoftware.com/cookie-policy)
Copyright © **Neocase Software**